Last updated on July 27th, 2010 at 02:07 pm
Its a shocking result today and yes Shivam Pathak is eliminated. Judges have already used their special power and shaved Rakesh maini last week so they can’t do anything this time. I am sure, they would have Shivam today if they had any power left. July 27 became unlucky day for Shivam Pathak and very lucky day for Swaroop. people were not thinking that Shivam Pathak will be eliminated at this stage. Swaroop and Bhoomi were expected.
Shivam has sung wonderfully yesterday and got very good comment. However, all other competitors sang very well yesterday and got wonderful comments from all judges.So it was really tough to decide the quality of singing based on yesterday’s performance. If we see all previous performances then of course Shivam was one of the best. Tho Shivam Pathak is eliminated, i am sure that he will be a well reputed singer in near future. He will surely be seen as a playback singer. I know many of you will wonder after knowing the results but similar things have been happening always so we have to face it. Its almost 100% sure that Sreeram is gonna lift the crown but none of us were expecting Shivam to be eliminated today.
Was the Decision of Judges to save Rakesh Maini Last week wise ? or it should have been used today for Shivam Today ? Lets watch the episode now.
Just look at the performances. Bhoomi and Swaroop are thinking that they will get eliminated and this could be their last performance in Indian Idol 5. Even Rakesh and Shivam were thinking about it but Shivam was very confident that he will be saved today.
Now watch the Shocking Results Announcement !!
Shivam Pathak’s Last performance in Indian idol 5 !
{ 38 comments… read them below or add one }
Shiv pathak was one of the strong contestant of Indain Idol 5 but in this stage anyone can be eliminated,so every one should keep in his mind this episode can be his last day in Indian Idol 5.Every one is good singer
i could not say whether judges made wise decision are rite or no. shivam is already a noted singer like shivam infact more versatile than sriram. every one ll be proud of working with these two. rakesh may or may not get that popular. may be by saving him through life line, he might get noted later on. im a big fan of shivam, his elimination was totally shocking to me, but he is already noted by every one and already proved infront of almost every one like amir khan, anu malik, saleem and sulaiman merchant etc etc etc. he has never been a bad singer right from the day one. as he said even i could not understand y he continues to be in bottom three though he is able to impress every one on stage. though judges could not help him anyways on indian idol stage, they could give him a chance in real time as they did for shriram. all big fans of shivam the most versatile singer on indian idol platform are waiting to see him as a best play back singer in few years.
I am sad by Shivam Pathak’s elimination but the competition is stiff and the other contestants are better . Next to go is Swaroop Khan ?
Rakesh has proved that the veto by judges was justified.
Best of luck to all four.
hmmm well i think shivam was 2nd best after shreeram and rakesh saving is not good he should b eliminated before but judges wrong decision bring bak rakesh i think bhoomi and rakesh should b eliminated best of luck for 4 of dem.
I think shivam is the best singer compare to rakesh! judges they did a wrong decision,sreeram is the 2010 indian idol thats for 100percent sure,iam the Big fan of sreeram.
Washington
USA
Judges have misused the opportunity…The only way they can use it 100% is “if at all sreeram is at the edge of elimination, even on the final’s day..judges has to use the chance and crown him”….remaining all are good..but …sreeram is 300% better than others..
Shivam’s elimination was not anticipated. If I had to rate top eight singers, my vote would be in the following order:
Sriram
Shivam
Rakesh
Shashi
Naushaad
Arpita
Swaroop
Bhoomi
Although Bhoomi has improved lately, she is still not on par with the top 4 mentioned above. Swaroop is ok at the best but lucky for sure.
The darl horse of this race is Rakesh because he has been the most improved singer in this competition. I like his voice and his confidence is going up day by day.
I predict Rakesh, Sriram and Bhoomi in Top 3 and although I wish Sriram wins the title, I think it’s be Rakesh who in the end will prevail.
It was wrong to save Rockesh….Mani and now see elimination of Shivam…
It was sad may due to his age or whatever he was eliminated which is totally rubbish and I don’t know why Swaroop Khan and bhomi is there.May be Anu like pretty faces thats why and judges should not be tharki and devdas
Hello All… Its really sad to see jerry mouse that is shivam getting eliminated.. Dono wat the audience is looking for???? There is a worst singer Swaroop Khan who should be eliminated if wild card is there plz judges get shivam back to the show…. Then only there will be a real competition in Indian Idol….He deserves friends..
i think swaroop was the worst among top5, in fact shashi, naushad were way better than swaroop. i hope he get’s eliminated next. for me shivam was the biggest n most deserving competitor of shreeram. am disheartened at his exit 🙁
Shivam was the most versatile singer among all the singers of Indian idol 5…I really wanted him to win Indian idol 5…I am very sad.
I was expecting Rakesh, Sreeram and Shivam in top three…For me Bhoomi and Swaroop should be eliminated.
I also think sreeram will be next indian idol and rakesh is 2nd runner
I am totally shocked to see Shivam go, he is a damn good singer compared to Swaroop. No offence to Swaroop he is good but he is not versatile enough like Shivam was. I am sure Shivam will find a playback opportunity soon in the near future, All the best to the surviving four and Sreeram is going all the way I believe,
Hi shivam,
Tuesday night ko tumhara eliminate hona really shocking tha. Fir bhi mere liye to tum hi Indian idol ho. Shivam aap mere bhai ke umar ke ho , shayad isiliye ya aur kuch vajah se aapke saath attachment hai. Shivam tum hamesha acche gaate ho. tumhari aawaz bahot acchi hai.tum versatile singerho. ye contest se nirash na hona. Apani ummid kayam rakhana. I think that voting by janta or elimination is the siliest way to choose the idol.swaroop ko tumse jyada vote mil gaye iski vajah kuch ar hai shayad.so don’t be nervous. Mein tumhe future me one of the top singer mein jarur dekhana chahungi.tum riyaz karo , aur bhi mehanat karo . tumhare kamyabi ki manzil tumhare bahot najdik hai.chill dood. Apni aawaz se duniya hila dena.I am dam shore you will rock the world.You are the best foreverrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr.keep going on.God bless you.
S- haan ho tum india ki.
H- ai tum me junun kuch karne ka.
I- ndian idol to bus ek choti si contest hai.
V- ictory to tumhari hogi.
A-im ko tumhe jinda rakhana hai.
M- ilegi khushiya , barsenge ful( flowers) tumhare jeevan mein.
I luv You Shivam. now i m very very very very very very very very very very very very ery very very very very very very very very very very very ery very very very very very very very very very very very ery very very very very very very very very very very very ery very very very very very very very very very very very sad
Shivam to bahut hee achha tha but bahan ke lode judges ki maa chud rahi thi jab rakesh bahan ka loda vapis ja raha tha .shivam if you r reading this than anu malik ki bahan sath me chod te hai
i think auidance will not aloow bhoomi to go as gujju will never never allow and same with swaroop next go is rakesh for sure and may be srerram as its now in auidance hand best of luck to all
I am in shock to about Shivam’s elimination.. Shivam was the best singer in the Idian Idol.. Now whoever will win it does’nt matter to me.. for me Shivam is still Real Indian Idol… Something sinister is going on in the elimination process.. I don’t think All Is Well there… Take the example of Kawa who never came in the bottom three till his elimination!!! And why Swroop is always in bottom and not eliminated… Just recall all the performances of all and decide by your own common sense..
Dear Baba.. as far as the trend of Indian Idol is concerned Shreeram is not going to lift the title.. Its always the lesser singer who lifted the title in Top.. Take my words…
i think rakesh should be eliminated.shivam is better than rakesh,bhoomi n swaroop.its wrong decision taken by judges by saving rakesh.
it is very bad judges misused that opprtunity last episode bcz shivam was one of best singer
may be its not correct decesion sreeram is the indian idol 5 winner
I DONT THINK IT WAS WISE FOR THE JUDGES TO USE THEIR OVER RULE POWER AT THIS POINT OF THE COMPETITION, AS NOW WE HAVE LOST THE MOST TALENTED CONTESTANT, WHO WOULD HAVE BEEN AT THE TOP TWO!SHIVAM WE WILL MISS YOU!
COMPETITION NOT THE SAME NOW.
i am sad that shivam was eliminated ….. Anu malik do a wrong decision to save rakhesh i pray god that the name of Top 2 is Sreeram.Swaroop khan
Good
I think Shivam should have been saved from Elimination first of all. Rakesh Maini is good but he is nothing compared to Sriram, Bhumi, Swaroop and Shivam. Rakesh is the weakest singer and Shivam is the best one. The judges decision is not wise at all.
aacha nehi hua.
shivam is a brilliant singer n i cnk mak out how cum da judges had 2 slice him 4m da show…he wud hav been da prfct competetr 4 da finalst…obviously sreeram…any wayz i wsh al luck 4 him n sreeram rckz…
Sreeram will be the next indian idol that is for sure. Sreeram you rock and keep rocking.
mujahe accha nahi laga shivam eliminated ho gaya so good singer anyway god bless you shivam………..i love you
all top 5 were fantastic.you are great bhoomi.win indian idol5
I have utmost respect for Shivam. he is Indian Idol Winner in my Eyes and I am
VERY VERY SERIOUS.
really shocking for me that one of my fav cont. shivam got eliminated ……….he is truly a a good singer ….I was expecting swroop Khan …but never mind ………now I pray for Shreeram…….he is damm good singer and truly deserve him …..
shukar hai ye koti ka bacha nikal giya haram zada tharki surlli mari jaaan hai
dear judges
dont ever pretend ok, when rakesh is been eliminated u should have accepted it. swroop and bhoomi are still there, how can u people use your power just like that.u should have left rakesh, see u saved a unwanted person, and lost a best person. when they give u power u should used it in a proper way, u should have thought twice before using the power. u people wasted it.
Shivam u r the great, don’t be sad dude,
salaa anumalik Tere kopodi meh 6 ke 6 utardu
kamini sunidi ,tere ko me raat dekaa ta hu ,
hi all..
sala koi bhi jite koi bhi haare, tumhare baap ka kya ja raha hai..
aaram se maza lo or mast raho
koi kuch nahi dene wala tumko salo..
shivam i love u